Gentleman of Leisure Stories

The soundtrack remains, but the storytellers who created it are leaving us one by one

Old Packinghouse Cafe, photo by author

I read this morning of the passing of David Clayton-Thomas, and I was saddened that another musical icon from our youth has slipped away. His powerful voice was part of a musical movement that didn’t just entertain us—it changed the course of history.

We didn’t discover music through algorithms or playlists. We found it on transistor radios tucked under our pillows after bedtime, spinning vinyl until the grooves wore thin, or crowding around someone’s basement stereo with friends who swore, "You’ve got to hear this." Every new album felt like an event. We memorized liner notes, argued over guitar solos, and knew the names of the musicians, not just the songs. Music wasn’t something we consumed—it became part of who we were.

It began in the 1950s with the sounds of Elvis Presley, Jerry Lee Lewis, Buddy Holly, and The Platters. Then came the '60s, when music carried our generation down a new road of freedom, peace, and brotherhood. These storytellers didn’t simply provide the soundtrack to our lives—they shaped the way we saw the world and influenced our journey into adulthood. Every band had its own fingerprint. You could tell the opening notes of Blood, Sweat & Tears from Chicago, The Band from Creedence Clearwater Revival, The Who from Led Zeppelin. Nobody was trying to sound like someone else. Individuality wasn’t just accepted—it was celebrated. That willingness to take chances gave us one of the richest periods of creativity popular music has ever known.

As each of these voices falls silent, I can’t help but feel we’re saying goodbye to more than remarkable musicians. We’re losing witnesses to a remarkable chapter of history. They sang through assassinations, war protests, civil rights marches, Woodstock, moon landings, and moments when it truly felt as though music could unite people who otherwise had nothing in common. With every obituary, another page of that living history quietly closes.

What saddens me most is realizing that, for many younger generations, that era has faded into history. The songs that stirred our souls, challenged our thinking, and gave voice to a generation are, to many, unknown. They can listen to the music, but they can never truly know what it felt like to live through it.

Catfish Platter Special, photo by author

These thoughts hung with me this afternoon as we ducked into the Old Packinghouse Café to escape the Florida heat. This 26-year-old character dive bar and restaurant is a Sarasota staple. As I scarfed down their fried catfish platter special, we watched the kids setting up for the afternoon’s jazz and blues session.

When I say the kids, let’s be honest—there wasn’t a soul on that stage under 55.

Maybe it's just the observations of an aging traveler, but I couldn't help wondering: Where are the young musicians who want to play this classic music that was supposed to last forever? The blues, jazz, rock, and soul that shaped our generation now seem to be carried almost exclusively by the generation that lived it.

The passing of David Clayton-Thomas only sharpened that thought. One by one, the voices that gave our generation its soundtrack are fading into history. Their music still plays, but who will keep it alive?

The Blood, Sweat & Tears song “When I Die” comes to mind. Clayton-Thomas sings about when he’s gone, and another child is born to carry on. But will there be?

Sign up here to receive our free weekly newsletter featuring the best of Crow’s Feet: Life As We Age.