In a ‘truly terrifying’ week, the nation responds

“Truly terrifying.” That was how National Nurses United Executive Director Puneet Maharaj described this week in a group text exchange in the aftermath of the brazen murder of Renee Nicole Good by Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE) agent Jonathan Ross in Minneapolis January 7.

A day later there was another shooting, some 1,700 miles away in Portland of Luis David Nico Moncada and Yorlenys Betzabeth Zambrano-Contreras in Portland by border patrol agents. And it was just a week after Keith Porter was shot and killed while celebrating on New Year’s Eve by an off-duty ICE agent in Northridge, CA, a Los Angeles suburb.

All three acts of violence capped a year in which the draconian anti-immigrant drive launched by President Trump and campaign architect Stephen Miller has terrorized immigrant communities and sparked protests across the nation. A year in which at least 32 people have also died in ICE custody, the agency’s most deadly year in decades, according to the Detention Watch Network. Some were long time residents some recent abductees in ICE raids. “They died of seizure and heart failure, stroke, respiratory failure, tuberculosis or suicide,” or reported neglect, notes the Guardian.

The shootings reflect the broad portrait of U.S. residents — Good, a white 37-year old, mother of three; Porter, a Black 43-year-old father of two; Moncada and Zambrano-Contreras, Venezuelan. And, in familiar tones, the Trump administration has been quick to demonize all four.

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem rushed to defend shooter Ross insisting it was an “act of domestic terrorism” by Good. Vice President Vance called Good a “deranged leftist.” Moncada and Zambrano-Contreras were immediately labeled as affiliated with the Tren De Aragua gang, though Portland officials voiced distrust in ICE characterizations. A DHS spokesperson claimed Porter was an “active shooter” and the off-duty agent was “protecting his community,” contentions that infuriated Porter’s friends.

The administration wants to control the Good investigation even as Minnesota officials say the federal government is impeding a state investigation. Vance claims agent Ross has “absolute immunity,” a point refuted by Harvard legal scholar Lawrence Tribe on MSNow with Lawrence O’Donnell. “State laws of assault continue to apply, even to a federal officer,” he noted. Outraged Minnesotans are calling for state prosecution as was done, with a conviction, for the police officer who killed George Floyd a short distance from where Good was murdered. Gov. Tim Walz says he wants the state to do a “full investigation.”

Community members gather at a vigil organized by Black Lives Matter-LA to pay tribute to Keith “Pooter” Porter. (Jason Armond / Los Angeles Times)

Porter’s friends are pushing for justice for Porter. Los Angeles County is “reviewing Porter’s killing,” though, the *Los Angeles Times* adds, “it sometimes takes years for the agency to determine if a deadly use of force constitutes a crime.” While Los Angeles is a “sanctuary city,” the LA Police Department is notorious for supporting and defending ICE and other federal immigration agents and constraining community protesters instead.

Venezuela, of course, was the other high-profile calamity of the week. Trump’s January 3 military invasion of Venezuela, kidnapping President Nicolas Maduro and his wife Cilia Flores, killing up up to 100 people, including civilians, Venezuelan officials report. The U.S. also bombed a medical warehouse, science labs, and an apartment complex along with other sites in Caracas.

The long planned assault followed months of extra-judicial bombings of boats in the Caribbean and Eastern Pacific that have executed at least 115 people since September — like the invasion, in violation of international and U.S. law, and without Congressional authorization.

It was a solemn beginning to the new year, an exclamation point on the past 12 months. The Trump administration has carried out the most sustained assault on Constitutional norms, dispatching of troops to threaten U.S. residents in numerous cities, weaponization of the Justice Department and programs to punish political enemies and entire Democratic-run states, shredding of decades of health care standards that have saved millions of lives, and so much more.

It’s hard to even get more appalled. But the convergence of the emergence of a new U.S. colonial empire abroad with the deadly escalation of Trump’s cruel, deadly and racist anti-immigrant program, is what made the week “truly terrifying.”

Many people on social media searched for analogs in recent U.S. history. For this aging lefty who lived through and participated in frequent protests against the Vietnam war, President Reagan’s sponsoring of military coups and mercenary armies in Latin America and the Caribbean, and the disastrous invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, I dredged up one comparison.

Ohio National Guard attacking Kent State University protesters, May 4, 1970

On April 28, 1970, President Nixon invaded Cambodia with combat troops, an enormous widening of the Southeast Asia war he had pledged to end. A week later on May 4, following days of protests, Ohio National Guard fired 67 rounds in 13 seconds at student protesters at Kent State University in Ohio, killing four students. I huddled around the radio listening to the accounts on Pacifica’s KPFA-FM with three roommates, thinking the world had dramatically changed in our lives. Then I rushed off to join a raucous protest at Sonoma State University where I was enrolled.

Many parallels to that time with this moment exist. There had been years of rallies and marches protesting Nixon and President Johnson’s war before him. Nixon was elected promising a secret plan to conclude the long Vietnam war while covertly sabotaging a long-delayed Johnson plan to initiate new peace talks. Trump campaigned as “peace” advocate, pledging to end “forever wars,” and begging for a Nobel Peace Prize before launching the most unchecked expansion of U.S. colonialism in more than a century.

The arrogant Nixon was, arguably, the most lawless President in U.S. history to that point, before being finally forced to resign. Trump has proven to be far worse, engaging in monarchical dictates and policies, running roughshod over Congress and defiance of the courts, staging an insurrection at the U.S. Capitol attempting to overturn the 2020 election, and now scheming how to subvert the 2026 and 2028 elections.

On the two arenas of the past week, Trump and his cabal are promising more. Trump has openly threatened to expand military operations to Cuba, Colombia, Mexico, and Greenland. “I don’t need international law,” Trump told the *New York Times*. He will only be constrained, he said, by his “own morality.”

Vance has intensified his increasingly desperate rhetoric to defend the murder of Good; the administration recognizes they have lost public support as millions have viewed the damning video evidence. Going on the attack, as Trump always requires when challenged, Vance boasts the administration has doubled its Gestapo-style police force to over 22,000, and plans to send ICE agents “door to door,” in coming months, mimicking the odious practices of past dictatorships. Trump has also threatened, again, to invoke the Insurrection Act to send the military to American cities to combat protesters.

Both Nixon and Trump have met massive opposition. Anti-Vietnam war marches mushroomed, with over half a million people joining a November 1969 march on Washington. I remember driving overnight from Los Angeles to San Francisco to march with 250,000 others across the city that same day. The repeated mobilizations, augmenting battlefield defeats in Vietnam, ultimately coerced the U.S. to end its war.

Trump has faced similar growing resistance. Up to 8 million Americans joined “No Kings” rallies and marches in June and October last year. And in the two days since the Minneapolis murder, thousands have turned out in spontaneous protests in many cities and smaller communities including Asheville, NC, Boston, Buffalo, Atlanta, Chicago, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Colorado Springs. CO, Columbus, OH, Dallas, Dayton, OH, Denver, Durham, NC, Los Angeles, Merrimack, NH, New Orleans, New York, Philadelphia, Phoenix, Providence, RI, Seattle, San Antonio, San Diego, San Francisco, Washington, and repeatedly in Minneapolis.

Trump’s stranglehold on Republican members of Congress is weakening. Trump lost two significant votes in Congress on January 7. Overriding House GOP leaders, 17 Republicans joined Democrats in the House to pass legislation to extend Affordable Care Act subsidies for three years as millions of Americans are facing calamitous increases in health care coverage due to GOP obstruction in the fall.

In the Senate, five Republicans joined in a “rare bipartisan rebuke of the White House” to set up a War Powers Resolution vote to require Congressional approval for Trump’s militarism in Venezuela and elsewhere. Incensed by the defiance, Trump said the five Republicans “should never be elected to office again.” Both actions face a difficult final outcome, but the votes are significant. It shows Republicans are worried about the approaching mid-term elections in November, following sweeping losses last year.

NNU members protest at University of California San Francisco Medical Center January 7

A wounded Trump, inclined to step up his callous attacks and lawlessness, is “truly terrifying” as NNU’s Maharaj noted. Responding, NNU lobbied for the ACA subsidy vote, condemned the Venezuela invasion and Good’s murder, and had members at the San Francisco protests. Nurses are among the rapidly expanding mass movement needed to protect democracy, human rights, and all who live here.