Ten Ways Autistic and Asperger’s Individuals Suffer as Family Scapegoats or Golden Children

Photo by Photogramy studio on Unsplash

I was ten years old when my parents called the police on me. Again. It wasn’t the first time, and it wouldn’t be the last — this happened every few weeks. I had been diagnosed with autism and Asperger’s years earlier, but my family reacted like they didn’t care. Or worse, like the diagnosis was just another inconvenience, another thing that made me difficult.

What made those years so confusing wasn’t just being autistic in a world that didn’t understand me. It was that I never knew which version of me would be acceptable on any given day. Some days, I was the golden child — praised, held up as an example. Other days, for reasons I couldn’t predict, I became the scapegoat — everything I did was wrong, evidence of how broken I was. The switch had nothing to do with my behavior and everything to do with my parents’ mood.

I’m twenty-nine now, turning thirty in five months and four days. It took me seventeen years to understand what happened to me, and I’m still unpacking it. When you’re autistic, and you’ve been assigned shifting roles in a dysfunctional family, the social challenges you already face become exponentially more complex and painful. These family dynamics don’t just add another layer of difficulty — they fundamentally distort how you understand yourself and your place in the world.

Here are ten ways this toxic combination manifests, drawn from research and from my own journey:

1. The “Double Empathy Problem” Becomes a Weapon

Autistic people communicate differently than neurotypical individuals, creating what researchers call the “double empathy problem” — a mutual challenge in understanding one another. In my case, my literal communication and struggle with unspoken social rules weren’t seen as neurodivergence. They were seen as defiance when I was the scapegoat, or as “quirks” that needed to be hidden when I was the golden child.

When you’re the scapegoat, every autistic trait becomes evidence of your moral failing. When you’re the golden child, you learn to suppress those same traits to maintain your favored status, essentially performing a neurotypical persona that exhausts you. I learned to do both, switching between them based on atmospheric pressure I couldn’t predict.

2. Sensory Overwhelm Gets Dismissed as “Drama”

Autistic individuals often experience sensory sensitivities — bright lights, loud noises, and certain textures can be genuinely painful, not just uncomfortable. This is neurological, not behavioral. But when you’re being scapegoated, your meltdowns or need for accommodations are labeled as attention-seeking or manipulation.

I remember the physical sensation of overwhelm — the way sounds would pierce through me, the way I needed to retreat to process. But there was no retreat. Instead, there were police officers in my home, treating my neurological distress as a behavioral problem. You learn to hide your sensory struggles, to suffer in silence, because showing vulnerability only makes things worse.

3. “Information Scapegoating” Intensifies

There’s a specific type of bullying that autistic people face called “information scapegoating” — being systematically targeted for knowing things or caring about accuracy when others prefer social consensus over facts. Autistic people often have a strong sense of truth and justice, and we struggle with inconsistency.

In dysfunctional families built on denial and maintaining appearances, this makes you dangerous. Your need for clarity, for things to make sense, threatens the family system. You get labeled as “too literal,” “pedantic,” “unable to let things go.” But you’re not being difficult — you’re trying to understand rules that keep changing based on someone else’s emotional state.

4. The Mask Becomes Your Identity

By the time the burnout hit, I didn’t know who I was anymore. I was in my twenties, and I spent my days writing in my journal and writing songs from my own heart — trying to find myself underneath all the layers of performance. But I was exhausted. Physically exhausted. Emotionally exhausted.

Many autistic people learn to “mask” — suppressing our natural behaviors to fit in. When you’re also navigating the golden child role, you’re not just hiding your autistic traits from the world; you’re hiding them from your family to keep their approval. This creates a double layer of performance that leads to profound burnout. You lose track of which version of you is real.

5. Social Skill Deficits Get Blamed, Not Taught

Autistic individuals often need explicit teaching about social rules that neurotypical people absorb intuitively. But when you’re the scapegoat, you don’t get taught — you get blamed. Every social misstep becomes more “evidence” of how you’re the problem child.

I internalized the belief that I was fundamentally flawed. Not different, not neurodivergent — broken. It never occurred to me that I simply processed social information differently and needed different kinds of support. Instead, I got police interventions and the message that my brain was something to be controlled, not understood.

6. Your Special Interests Become Ammunition

Music and writing were my refuges, the places where I could process and make sense of things. But in a dysfunctional family, your passionate interests either get mocked or commodified. When I was the scapegoat, my writing was dismissed or criticized. When I was the golden child, my achievements might be praised — but only when they served the family’s image, never for the genuine passion and need they represented for me.

Your interests are either weaponized or exploited, never simply accepted as the vital part of your autistic experience that they are.

7. The Exhaustion is Compounded and Leads to Dangerous Self-Blame

The burnout wasn’t just tiredness. It came with intense anger — at myself. I was angry at myself for not meeting expectations, angry for every social mistake, and angry for needing accommodations that were denied. All three: the expectations I couldn’t meet, the mistakes I couldn’t prevent, the needs I couldn’t eliminate.

Being autistic in a neurotypical world is already exhausting. Adding the constant vigilance required in a dysfunctional family system — where you’re either dodging blame or maintaining a performance, where you never know which role you’ll be playing tomorrow — creates a level of burnout that’s hard to articulate. You’re managing sensory input, decoding social situations, and navigating an unpredictable environment where the rules change based on a parent’s mood.

8. You’re Isolated from Understanding Peers

Autistic individuals often connect more easily with other autistic people, where the double empathy problem disappears. But scapegoated autistic children get isolated — controlled, kept from activities, or so damaged by the home environment that forming friendships feels impossible.

It wasn’t until I was in PHP (Partial Hospitalization Program) and IOP (Intensive Outpatient Program) — and critically, not in Tallahassee, not in my hometown — that I found people who understood. These weren’t necessarily other autistic people, but they were people who understood trauma. People with similar or related diagnoses who have learned what it means to survive a childhood like mine.

Those friendships, formed away from the place where everything happened, became part of my healing. Sometimes you need distance — literal, geographical distance — to find people who can see you clearly.

9. Misdiagnosis and Pathologization Create Confusion

I was diagnosed with autism and Asperger’s as a child. But my family’s response was to call the police, not to seek understanding or accommodations. The diagnosis became another weapon, another way I was “the problem.”

Many adult autistic survivors spend years trying to untangle which challenges are autistic traits and which are trauma responses. Social anxiety from being autistic? Or from being punished for autistic traits? Difficulty with executive function from ADHD? Or from complex PTSD? The lines blur when your neurodivergence is treated as something to be controlled rather than understood.

10. The Recovery Journey is Uniquely Complex

Healing from family scapegoating requires recognizing manipulation, setting boundaries, and often going no-contact. For autistic individuals, this is complicated by literal thinking — difficulty recognizing covert manipulation when people don’t say what they mean. It’s complicated by attachment to routines, even toxic ones, because routine provides the predictability our nervous systems crave.

Recovering from the golden child role means dismantling a false self while grieving the approval you’ll lose. For autistic individuals, this means discovering your authentic neurodivergent identity that’s been suppressed your entire life.

It took burnout, anger, years of writing in journals and writing songs to find my own voice, and eventually finding people outside my hometown who understood trauma — all of that before I could even begin to untangle who I actually am versus who I was forced to perform being.

Moving Forward

I’m still on this journey. At twenty-nine, approaching thirty, I’m still learning to distinguish between my autistic traits and my trauma responses. Still learning what accommodations I actually need versus what coping mechanisms I developed to survive.

If you recognize yourself in these patterns, know that you’re not alone. The intersection of autism and dysfunctional family dynamics is finally getting more attention, and survivors like us are finding each other and sharing our stories.

Your social challenges were never character flaws. The role you were assigned — whether scapegoat, golden child, or both — was never your fault. The diagnosis your family dismissed or weaponized was real, and it deserved understanding and support, not police interventions.

Recovery involves:

• Seeking therapists who understand both autism and family trauma
• Connecting with communities where you can be yourself — sometimes far from where the trauma happened
• Learning to distinguish between autistic traits and trauma responses
• Grieving the family support you deserved but never received
• Building accommodations for your actual neurotype, not the person you were forced to pretend to be
• Finding people who understand trauma, who see you, who believe you

You deserve relationships where your autism is accepted, where you’re not walking on eggshells, and where your worth isn’t contingent on performing a role or managing someone else’s mood. That’s not just possible — it’s your right.

The police should never have been called. You should have been supported, not controlled. And the fact that you survived, that you’re here reading this or writing your own story — that matters. Your journal entries, songs, and efforts to understand yourself were never the problem. They were acts of resistance and self-preservation.

Keep writing. Keep finding your voice. Keep connecting with people who understand. The distance you’ve traveled — from twelve to twenty-nine, from confusion to clarity — is remarkable. And there’s more healing ahead.