What We Learned Testing A New Music Quiz Game Mode Before Launch

Launching a new feature without testing it with real users is a gamble. No matter how polished a prototype looks, users ALWAYS interact with it in ways we, as designers and product teams, never anticipate.

I recently led a moderated usability test for Muzingo’s new ‘Music IQ Game Mode’ at Charisol. Our goal was simple: To understand the user experience, pinpoint friction, and uncover opportunities to make it truly engaging before launch. The sessions were incredibly insightful, validating some assumptions and completely challenging others.

Photo by Bluestonex on Unsplash

Here are some key lessons we learned about building a music-based quiz game users will love:

1. Punishing failure too harshly kills motivation: Users got frustrated losing all progress after one mistake. I realized that while challenge is good, an unfair penalty makes players abandon the game rather than try harder.

Recommended Improvement: We needed to balance challenge with a sense of progress, perhaps through a scoring or XP system.

2. Personalization isn’t a bonus; it’s an expectation: Users want to choose their preferred music genres. Presenting everyone with the same question pool reduces engagement.

Recommended Improvement: Allowing players to customize their experience (genres, difficulty) makes the game feel more relevant.

3. Repetitive questions quickly lead to boredom: When participants noticed repeated questions, it reduced their incentive to play. Content variety is crucial for replayability; expanding the question bank is key.

Recommended Improvement: Expanding the question bank significantly would help reduce repetition. In the long term, AI-assisted question generation could provide an effective way to continuously introduce fresh content while maintaining quality and accuracy.

Photo by Desola Lanre-Ologun on Unsplash

4. Progress saving is non-negotiable: Losing current level progress due to interruptions or simply leaving the game was a major pain point. Users expect modern apps to remember where they left off. It’s a basic expectation.

Recommended Improvement: Implement a system that automatically saves player progress and allows users to resume exactly where they stopped.

5. Rewards and competition drive long-term engagement: Many suggested adding rewards (streaks, badges, XP) and multiplayer functionality. Knowledge alone attracts, but gamification and social competition sustain engagement.

Recommended Improvements: Introduce rewards such as Daily login streaks, Weekly challenges, XP systems, Unlockable badges, Coins or points redeemable for hints and special features etc. These mechanics create additional motivation without distracting from the core gameplay.

6. Small details have a big impact: Even something as simple as background music during gameplay was requested to enhance immersion and thematic consistency.

Recommended Improvement: Introduce multiplayer functionality that allows friends to challenge each other and compete in live quiz sessions. This could significantly increase engagement and organic user growth.

Photo by Kenny Kennethh on Unsplash

7. Players Want Recognition and Shareable Achievements: Users showed strong interest in sharing their results and receiving personalized recognition for their music knowledge. People enjoy showcasing their accomplishments, especially when those accomplishments represent their interests and identity.

Recommended Improvement: Create shareable achievements and music identity badges such as Afrobeat Fan, Wizkid Top Fan, Music Expert, Genre Specialist etc. These achievements can encourage social sharing while helping users build a sense of accomplishment.

Conclusion

These sessions reinforced a vital lesson: Users rarely struggle with what we expect, and they often identify opportunities we never considered. Usability testing didn’t just uncover problems; it provided a clear roadmap for building a product that users genuinely enjoy returning to.

It’s why testing before launch isn’t just about fixing bugs; it’s about building for growth and user delight.

UserTesting #ProductDesign #UsabilityTesting #ProductDevelopment #UserExperience

Need a Product Designer who thinks beyond UI? Let’s connect