Childfree Women Still Have a Clock

No One Wants to Be Someone’s Gap Year Before Fatherhood

One thing about myself is that I enjoy learning from elderly people. Listening to their stories and what they would have done differently has helped mold me.

Years ago, I met an older woman, Lena, who was happily married and who helped me through a dilemma I was quietly wrestling with at the time. She talked with me with the calm authority of a woman who had survived plenty of dating disasters.

She said, *“I only dated artists, musicians, and weirdos.” *Which, honestly, sounds both like advice and a warning.

As a dating pool, these type of men have their issues, but let’s not romanticize a man with a guitar too quickly. I’ve fallen for a musician or two back in my day and felt like a muse on Friday, only to be asked if he could borrow rent money on Monday.

But I had to agree, they weren’t the kind of men seeking a traditional life with children.

“Stay away from the normies,” she warned.

I laughed, but I also understood what she meant. The “normie” script is popular and usually looks like: date for a couple of years, marriage, a house, then children. It’s not in that order for everyone, but most people want some version of the script.

For others, like me, we’d like to substitute one or two items in the script with travel, adventure, or a career.

During my 20s, I learned what I liked and was forming an idea of how I wanted to live my life. Training and exercise made me feel good physically and, more importantly, emotionally. One-night stands allowed me to explore my sexual preferences. Dating allowed me to become a better partner in my later years and what to appreciate as well as avoid in men.

So, being reminded of my dilemma from years ago during a group conversation, I found myself empathizing with a woman who felt the same as I did back in my 20s.

Because back then, I too had decided that I never wanted to have a child.

Photo by Tim Mossholder on Unsplash

Hanging out with friends, and friends of friends, because apparently nobody can just hang with only their friends anymore, a very touchy topic came up… marriage.

One of the men was being honest and asked, “What’s the point of marriage if you don’t want kids?” And I wasn’t surprised to see the group split.

The woman who brought up the topic was approaching 30 and shared she was struggling to find a man who didn’t want children. She admitted that some have said they were fine with not having children… right now.

Of course, these men wanted to date her because she was attractive, but balked at marriage when they realized she really didn’t want children.

This smart, beautiful woman couldn’t find a man she liked who genuinely did not want children.

According to her, every guy she met eventually hit her with some version of, “Yeah, but I want a family one day.” Then another guy in the group, sitting next to his girlfriend, said, “Well, there’s no real incentive for marriage if kids aren’t the goal.” The girlfriend sat silent as the conversation continued.

But before I could respond, I looked at the woman who had started the conversation. She had gone quiet in a way I recognized. Not offended, but the kind of quiet where you realize a problem may be bigger than you originally thought.

Because she wasn’t just asking, “How do I find a man who doesn’t want kids?”

She was really asking, “How do I find a man who believes a life with just me is enough?”

And that is a very different question.

[embed]She Was the “Dream Wife”, Until She Mentioned Money The internet loves a fantasy. In reality? Not so much.medium.com

My friend’s reaction reminded me of Lena and how she helped me when I was contemplating whether I should have agreed to one day have a child to save my relationship.

Today, I’m super glad I didn’t, but I really thought hard about it after hearing her story.

Back then, Lena was a woman of thirty-two, childfree, and very clear about it. She was the “I enjoy quiet mornings, disposable income, and not having spit up on my shirt” kind of childfree.

This was before dating apps, but all her online profiles said the same, “No children. Not now. Not ever.” And still, men thought they could change her mind and tried to debate her.

For a childfree woman, the danger is not a man who clearly says he wants children. That man is easy enough to identify, so you can wish him well, pack your emotional bags, and get off the train before it leaves the station.

The more dangerous man for a childfree woman is the vague one. The “I haven’t really thought about it” or “let’s see what happens” man costs a woman years.

One fateful day, Lena met Daniel.

He was forty-two, divorced, silver-haired, and handsome. This man listened when she spoke and did not interrupt her to explain something she had to pretend to be interested in, like cold plunges or intermittent fasting.

His two daughters were 13 and 15.

On their third date, Lena told him directly, “I don’t want kids.” Daniel reached across the table and touched her hand.

“I already did that,” he said. “And I’m not looking to start over.”

There it was, the sentence every childfree woman wants to hear. So she relaxed. Daniel was telling the truth because that is how he felt at that moment, which is how most people tell the truth right before they admit to themselves that they lied.

For the first two years, he was lovely.

He learned how she took her coffee and that she hated cilantro. Sparkling water was kept in his fridge because she liked it. He had a dog named Miles who treated Lena with suspicion at first, but eventually accepted her after she started arriving with bacon.

I mean, who doesn’t like bacon? (Yeah, I know… vegans)

She began imagining a life with him as their relationship blossomed. Not a nursery or school pickup. Her version of a future together was quieter. The life partner she knew would sit next to her hospital bed and her to his.

What is that, if not family?

Then Daniel’s younger sister got pregnant. At first, it was sweet, and he had tears in his eyes when he found out. The kind men try to hide by suddenly becoming very interested in their phones. It just made Lena love him more.

But after the baby arrived, something shifted.

Daniel became a man possessed by baby clothes and photos of his nephew. He started saying things like, “Look at his little fingers,” with the emotional intensity of someone witnessing a miracle.

And then one day, she was carrying his nephew and making him giggle when he said, “You are amazing with kids.”

Lena laughed it off.

“I’m amazing with kids because I can give them back.”

A week later: “You never know. Life surprises people.”

She looked at him carefully. “Daniel.” “What?” “You know I don’t want children.” “I know,” he said. “I’m just saying people change.”

People do change. That is one of the terrible facts of being in love. You fall for someone as they are, and then life keeps editing them without asking your permission.

Still, Lena told herself that he was not asking her for another child. He had already experienced school plays, fevers, teenage attitudes, and the particular hell of finding her favorite doll five minutes before leaving the house.

Then one evening, while they were cleaning up after dinner, he said it, “I know this may sound crazy.”

Which is how people introduce something they know is absolutely going to lead to an argument. So, he leaned against the counter and waited until after Lena finished doing the dishes and dried her hands to continue.

“Being around the baby has made me realize how much I wish I had a son.”

There are moments in a relationship when the world changes shape. For Lena, the lights seemed to be brighter, and the room felt bigger.

“What are you asking me?” she asked, already aware of the answer.

Daniel rubbed his face, but answered, “I don’t know.”

And there it was, one of the most annoying sentences in dating. People think cruelty sounds like shouting. Other times, it sounds like uncertainty.

Sometimes it sounds like a man who has enjoyed your body, humor, companionship, tenderness, Saturday mornings, and ability to make his life less lonely, then looks at you like you have betrayed him by still being exactly who you said you were.

Lena reminded him of their third date.

“You told me you were done.”

“I thought I was.”

“You knew I didn’t want children.”

“I know.”

“So what changed?”

He looked genuinely pained, which somehow made it worse.

“I guess I didn’t realize how much I still wanted that feeling.”

That feeling.

Not the vomit at 3 a.m., the appointment scheduling, putting his career on hold, or the sacrifice to her body. Not the remembering of shoe sizes, food allergies, permission slips, the school commitments, the dentist appointments, the snack inventory.

This was a man standing in the kitchen with a woman who had been honest from the beginning, wondering if she might become a different woman so he could revisit an old version of himself.

Supposedly, Lena did not yell, but I damn sure would have yelled, because I am Latina and we can be dramatic. But Lena got very quiet.

Because she had to ask. “If I never have children, would a life with me be enough?”

Daniel opened his mouth, but there was only his breath. When he closed it without a word, she had her answer. Sometimes hesitation says more than any word can.

They broke up two weeks later. Not because they stopped loving each other. That would have been easier.

I’ve learned that there is a special kind of grief in leaving someone while love is still looking at both of you like it did nothing wrong, confused about why it is not enough.

For almost a year, Lena wondered if she had made a mistake.

Because Daniel was not a villain, and that was the part that made it hard. He had not lied or cheated. His only crime was that he had been vague with himself first.

And it cost Lena her most painful heartbreak. That is the cruelty of uncertainty. It does not always arrive with bad intentions. Sometimes it arrives with good memories, a decent man, and a dog you miss more than you expected.

A couple of years later, Lena saw Daniel at a farmer’s market, because life has a terrible sense of humor.

He was with his daughter, a baby, and a woman a little younger than Lena was now. The woman was smiling at the baby with the sincere delight of becoming a mother.

They looked… happy.

Lena stood there holding asparagus and thought, Daniel had not left her for a better woman. He had simply left for a different life. And she had kept herself from being dragged into it.

That was the twist.

A childfree woman is often told she has all the time in the world. And yes, there is freedom in that, but her time is still not disposable. Her thirties are not a sabbatical that uncertain men can enjoy until they are ready for fatherhood.

If two people love each other, protect each other, share a home, build rituals, survive illnesses, pay bills, disappoint each other, forgive each other, make coffee, walk/bury pets, host friends, fight over thermostat settings, and know which side of the bed the other person prefers…

…then it should not end with one person realizing they were helping build a future they were never meant to be a part of.

A childfree woman may not have a biological clock, but her clock of youth starts ticking when she invests her best years in someone who sees her as just a chapter before his real life begins.

And no woman should have to become a mother just to prove she was worthy of being called family.

[embed]He Ordered Two Coffees. I Should Have Left. One Reason Some Men Struggle With Datingmedium.com

Thank you for reading and if you enjoyed please make sure to clap for this story or leave a comment.

Looking for date ideas and/or want to make new friends. Then join our community at FunDateJar.