The Bagel Shop Prophet

An 82-year-old man in a bagel store accidentally talked me off a ledge

Image created by author.

I was staring at the syrup bottles behind the counter. The ones they put in coffee drinks. I don’t drink coffee, so I don’t speak that language, but the bottles are pretty, different colors, nice fonts, and I had nowhere else to put my eyes. Normally I’d be on my phone scrolling like everyone else. Not that morning. That morning I was just standing there absorbing colors like a houseplant.

Running on four hours of sleep and a full night of convincing myself I was too much and still somehow not enough, my father was spiraling about my mother’s headstone. My ex called to use me as a punching bag about his job. My brother had his own crisis going on. Everybody needed something and nobody particularly cared how I was doing.

My 24-year-old had opinions about my personal life that I did not ask for, specifically about the man in my life who knows every single thing about me and calls anyway, which somehow made everything worse. When someone’s being good to you and you’re too depleted to receive it properly, that has its own particular weight. I was carrying all of it. None of it dramatic enough to name out loud. All of it heavy enough that standing in a bagel store on a Wednesday morning was genuinely the most I could manage. Staring at bottles I’d never use.

Then somebody tapped my arm.

I’ve seen him in this bagel store for three years. I don’t know his name. He doesn’t know mine. He’s 82, Jewish, a certain kind of older New Yorker who is his own complete category of person. He shows up on weekends with little test tubes so kids can blow bubbles, hands them out to strangers, tells them it’s another way to make the day more beautiful. He gave me one too. He talks to everyone and he means it every time.

He ordered a bagel and a coffee, then came and stood next to me.

“Hey,” he said. “I got something I want to tell you.”

I looked at him. I knew this wasn’t weird. This was just what he did.

“I don’t want to know your name,” he said. “I don’t want to know what you do. But I’m going to tell you something.”

“Okay,” I said. Or something like it.

He started talking about gratitude.

Not in a therapy way or an Instagram way. He talked about it like he meant every word.

“People think heaven is up there,” he said, pointing at the ceiling. “But I don’t hear from any of my dead friends. Nobody’s called me.” And then he shrugged. “So it must be right here.”

“Don’t let people ruin your day. You’re the only one responsible for that. Appreciate the people in your life while they’re here.”

That’s the kind of thing that sounds like a magnet on someone’s fridge until an 82-year-old man says it to you while someone in the back is making your egg sandwich.

He touched my arm. Gently. Just to make sure I was still with him.

I was barely keeping up, but I got through it anyway.

The cashier called over at some point. Time to pay. He held up one hand without turning around. Not yet.

I laughed. The cashier laughed. Everyone in there knew him and nobody was surprised.

Then he said he had a song. An original song.

He sang it quietly, just between the two of us, right there by the syrup bottles. It was about gratitude and about being somebody worth something, the kind of song that sounds ridiculous until you’re the person it’s aimed at. He spelled it out, g-r-a-t-i-t-u-d-e, rhyming it with attitude, a little original ditty delivered with complete sincerity and absolutely no self-consciousness about any of it on a Wednesday morning. It wasn’t for the room. It was just for me.

I stood there nodding and smiling and somewhere around the second verse I had to look at the ceiling for a second.

When he finished he touched my arm one more time.

“You have a great day, Miss,” he said. “And remember everything I told you.”

Then he turned around, walked straight to the register, and said, “Okay, where’s my bagel?” Like nothing had happened. Like a prophet with better things to do.

I walked out to my car, maybe 20 seconds from the door, and I didn’t start it right away. I just sat there. The first thing I did was text the one person who’d actually want to hear it. Still in the parking lot, engine off, I typed out what had just happened because I needed to tell somebody before I drove away.

I wasn’t crying exactly. It wasn’t sadness and it wasn’t excitement. It was a kind of relief I don’t have a word for.

I thought about my father. My ex. The man in my life who texts me about birds and crossword clues and whether I’ve eaten. My daughters. My friends, the ones who still call, the ones who show up.

The old guy in the bagel store who shows up on weekends with bubble wands for strangers and some mornings apparently with songs for women who look like they could use one.

Because when I actually look at my life, and not the 2AM version, it’s just full.

I don’t hear from my dead friends either. Nobody’s called. One of my closest friends from college hasn’t called, and he would have found a way if there was one. My cousin Tommy hasn’t called either, and trust me, that man would have figured out the technology. My grandmother hasn’t called either. Nobody’s called.

Which maybe means this is it. This loud, weird, exhausting, occasionally beautiful Wednesday morning with bagels on the passenger seat.

I’m not sure I’m there yet. But I heard him.