I Said “I Hear You” While Losing My Mind

My Misadventures In Being The Calm Parent

Photo by Zahir Namane on Unsplash

Gentle Parenting Is Harder When Nobody Gentle-Parents The Mother

I first learned gentle parenting from a woman on my phone who spoke in a voice so soft it made me suspicious of her plumbing.

She had beige shelves, wooden toys, a child with clean hair, and captions about regulation, connection, nervous systems, repair, and naming feelings before correcting behavior. I watched her while standing in my kitchen with dish soap on my wrist and a piece of cereal stuck to the side of my foot, nodding like a fool because I wanted so badly to become the kind of mother who did not damage her child through tone.

I was not raised gently, which is not a confession people know what to do with unless you make it neat. My parents were not monsters. They fed us, paid school fees, kept the lights on, and believed fear was an acceptable shortcut to obedience because most adults around them believed the same thing. Teachers did it too. A slammed ruler on a desk. A child humiliated for crying. A note in red ink that felt less like correction than a verdict on your whole nervous little body.

So when I became a mother, I made the usual promise women make before reality starts chewing the edges off it.

I will not be like that.

I thought gentle parenting would save me from becoming the sharp woman I feared was already living under my skin. I bought the language like emergency supplies. “I see you are upset.” “Your feelings are allowed, but hitting is not.” “I am here when you are ready.” I practiced the sentences in the bathroom mirror once, which is humiliating to admit because I looked less like a wise mother and more like a hostage reading a statement prepared by a committee.

The assumption was that if I stayed calm, my child would eventually borrow my calm.

That assumption was incomplete in the way a bridge can be incomplete.

One Tuesday morning, my son wanted the blue bowl, not the green bowl, though the blue bowl was in the dishwasher under a spoon with peanut butter welded to it. I explained this with the patient voice. He screamed. I offered the green bowl. He knocked it off the counter. Oatmeal slid down the cabinet door in a slow beige curtain, and I remember staring at it with actual scientific interest, as if my life had become a physics demonstration sponsored by resentment.

I crouched down and said, “You are disappointed because you wanted the blue bowl.”

He screamed louder.

I said, “It is hard when things do not go the way we hoped.”

He kicked the cabinet.

Somewhere behind me, the washing machine beeped like it had an opinion.

By the time my husband came in, freshly showered and smelling like mint toothpaste and adult freedom, I was sitting on the floor beside the oatmeal, using a dish towel to wipe one sticky stripe from my ankle. He looked at our son, looked at me, and said, “Why don’t you just give him something else?”

There are moments in marriage when a woman discovers whole new rooms inside her anger.

I did not scream at my child that morning. I screamed at my husband, which is apparently not covered in the gentle parenting modules, though I think it should be, because many mothers are not actually failing at parenting alone. They are failing inside a household where everyone expects them to be the emotional climate control system while other adults drift in with suggestions.

Later, at school pickup, I told another mother I was struggling with gentle parenting, and she gave me the look women give when they want to seem compassionate while placing themselves slightly above you. Her name was Melissa, and she always wore athletic clothes despite never appearing to sweat. She said, “I just try to meet my child where he is.”

Her son was behind her licking the metal railing near the entrance.

I said nothing because I am working on being less unpleasant in public, or maybe only less traceable.

Melissa added that children act out when they do not feel safe enough to express themselves, and I understood then why some women are disliked even when they are technically saying something correct. She was not wrong. That was the worst part. My son does need safety. He does need help with feelings. I do not want to frighten him into compliance like a little employee with no union.

But I also needed someone to acknowledge that a mother can believe in emotional safety and still want to throw a plastic dinosaur into the yard.

The backlash against gentle parenting makes sense to me now, though I distrust some of it. There are parents who hear “gentle” and immediately celebrate the return of shouting, spanking, and the old kingdom of adult convenience. I do not want that either. I have seen what fear does to children. It makes them quiet, not good. It makes them sneaky, not respectful. It teaches them to read footsteps before they learn to read themselves.

But the online version of constant calm has its own cruelty.

It asks mothers to become trauma-informed saints while running on interrupted sleep, school notices, unpaid house labor, grocery math, marital disappointment, and a body that has been touched all day by people who need something. It tells us to regulate before responding, but nobody asks who regulated us after a child spit toothpaste on the mirror, the eggs burned, the phone rang, and a relative texted asking why we never call.

Gentle parenting often assumes the parent has a self left to govern.

Some days I do. Some days I am a collection of errands wearing leggings with a hole near the waistband.

The strangest part is that gentle parenting did change me, just not in the clean way I expected. It made me hear my own voice more clearly. It made me notice how quickly anger rises when I feel ignored, not only by my child, but by the whole structure around motherhood. It made me see that I was not only trying to raise a kind child. I was trying to rewrite my own childhood through him, which is a heavy job to hand to a boy who still cries because his toast broke wrong.

That realization did not make me softer.

It made me more suspicious of my motives.

Sometimes I am gentle because my child needs gentleness. Sometimes I am gentle because I am terrified of being judged. Sometimes I am gentle because I want to prove I am better than the adults who scared me. Sometimes I am not gentle at all, only quiet, and there is a difference my son probably feels before I do.

Last week he threw a sock at my face because I said no more cartoons before school. It hit my cheek, damp from where he had chewed the edge of it for reasons known only to children and possibly wolves. I closed my eyes and said, “I will not let you throw things at me.”

He yelled that I was a bad mother.

I wanted to say, “You have no idea how hard I am trying not to be.”

Instead, I took the remote and put it on top of the refrigerator, where all broken negotiations go to die.

He cried. I made toast. My husband asked if we were out of coffee. Nobody in the room looked transformed.

That afternoon, my son brought me a drawing from school. It was me with very long arms and a square head. He had colored my hair orange by mistake and then said it was because I was “a little bit fire.”

I did not know whether to laugh or apologize.

Maybe gentle parenting is not the problem. Maybe the problem is how easily women are handed impossible standards and then blamed for the noise they make while trying to carry them. Maybe the old way was cruel and the new way can become another performance, another unpaid shift, another script mothers recite while the oatmeal hardens on the cabinet.

Tonight I will probably try again.

I will lower my voice. I will name the feeling. I will fail somewhere around bedtime when the pajama shirt is suddenly unacceptable because the dinosaur is facing the wrong direction.

The blue bowl is clean now.

I have hidden it in the back of the cabinet, which may not be gentle, but is certainly parenting.

Thank you for reading my story. If you enjoy reading my stories, feel free to buy me a Coffee.

Welcome to submit your original works and impactful stories. We publish original articles that offer clear lessons, drawing on real-world experiences, relevant examples, and practical takeaways for readers.

[embed]Kurious Minds Pub “Kurious Minds” is a publication offering personal essays on life, growth, and happiness. We publish original writing…medium.com

Story edited by The KURIOUSK, Ph.D.

[embed]The KURIOUSK, Ph.D. — Medium Read writing from The KURIOUSK, Ph.D. on Medium. Professor & storyteller. Sharing real-life lessons, behind-the-scenes…medium.com