Why User-Generated Content Outperforms Traditional Ads — and How AI Makes It Even Stronger

Yesterday I had a nightmare, and woke up thinking that my TikTok had been deleted.

Can you imagine the horror of waking up and thinking you had a TikTok account?!

I’m just kidding… sort of… because while I’m probably too old to be on TikTok myself, I can’t really say that I don’t use it, or that it’s not important.

If you don’t believe me, just look at the statistics, and you’ll see that UGC, or User-Generated Content, is taking over from traditional advertising.

Photo by Look Studio on Unsplash

I don’t blame them either, if you ask anyone, they’ll tell you that a real person giving an opinion is worth a lot more than a bunch of ads.

That’s been true since I was a teenager, learning how to shop around for the best products and prices, and it’s still true today.

Knowing it is one thing, though, and seeing the financial facts is another — so let me lay a few on you.

Some recent research from AdWeek shows that UGC is taking the stage, exceeding conversions for traditional ads by nearly 29%!

Aside from the fact that actual people are just more trustworthy than ads, I can tell you why in one single sentence.

Everybody hates ads, they flood our view everywhere we look, so much that we’ve all learned to ignore them.

On the other hand, though, when an actual human being tells me, “This is a great product, I just used it and look how well it works,” I’m a lot more inclined to believe them.

So that brings us to today’s big topic: how can we bring the power of AI to bear for creating more UGC, without, this is important, without replacing humans with AI?

That last part is super, super important, because if you start generating AI “users” and your customers find out, you’re going to lose all their trust and purchasing power.

Nobody likes being lied to, and nobody likes being told a person is real when they’re actually AI. So every one of these techniques neatly avoids that pitfall.

We’re not talking about how to replace humans with AI, we’re talking about how to get the most bang for our buck by using AI data analysis techniques to supercharge our human representatives.

As with any advertising techniques, the best options may evolve over time — but right here and now, these are the three top-performing strategies and how they can help.

Photo by Melanie Deziel on Unsplash

1. The Three R’s: Research, Research & Research

All the best ads start with research, and I know it’s boring and time consuming, but that’s why AI is so popular right now.

It does all the slowest, most tedious parts in a flash.

In this case, it can support your research in three key areas. First, it delivers instant insights into what’s currently working best for your competitors. Second, it highlights the concepts and creative styles that are trending right now. Third, it helps you evaluate your own ads by identifying what’s performing well and where improvements can be made.

All of these topics require research anyway, if you want the best results. AI just does it a whole lot faster.

2. Genuine & Timely

In my experience, one of the biggest problems today is not just making genuine content, but getting it out fast enough that it still hits the right spot with the consumers.

Everything moves so fast today. What’s funny right now will be cliche by next week, and that incentivizes a lot of brands to make fake AI content, pretending to be real people. It really helps with the deadlines, and staying on top of trends.

We don’t need to do that, though, and we shouldn’t, because as we discussed earlier, your customers will eventually find out, and they will not be pleased.

Instead, get the best of both worlds by using AI to help narrow down your topics, generate scripts, and find the most effective strategies for right now, so you can release completed copies before they get stale.

With the right AI tools and techniques, you can do this nearly as fast as using a fully AI-generated system, but your content will be a lot better with a human in the loop, and your customers will appreciate it.

Photo by Windows on Unsplash

3. Templates & Variations

Just because your human users have to actually be human doesn’t mean you can’t do a lot of the heavy lifting with AI.

Some of the best uses I’ve seen so far are for adding variation to ads to make multiple versions, or building multiple ads from a few high-converting templates.

Obviously, you still want to keep your genuine human involved, and you don’t want to use the AI to change their words, but you can use it to change the background, text, visuals, or other parts of your campaign, instantly.

Sometimes this lets you create an entirely new campaign with just a few clicks, or you can use it to build several options, and see which ones do best.

While the new AI tools are tempting, it’s far too easy to go too deep, and ending up creating fully synthesized AI slop pretending to be real human beings.

We should all be using AI in our ad campaigns, it cuts the time and cost down dramatically, without reducing the effectiveness at all, but there has to be a limit.

With the right tools, we can analyze, edit, clone, or compare ads pretty much instantly — just don’t fall into the trap of creating them fully from AI, if you want to keep your clients coming.

If you have the right tools, it’s easy to do it the right way, and the returns are better too.