INTR6169029 — LA68 - Rheney Adinda Wahyudi- 2501977456

The Riau Islands as a Trafficking Hub: Examining Indonesian Migrant Worker Exploitation in Johor Bahru

Fauziyah, N. N., & Arkyasa, M. (2023, September 14). KJRI Johor Bahru repatriates 6 human trafficking victims in Malaysia. Tempo.co English. https://statik.tempo.co/data/2023/02/24/id_1183815/1183815_720.jpg

Human trafficking remains a grave violation of basic human rights because it preys on the vulnerabilities of those in search of a brighter future. Exploiting vulnerable individuals seeking better economic prospects, traffickers resort to deceit and manipulation to further their selfish interests (Langie, 2024). The global community must come together to address this pervasive criminal activity that poses a significant threat to human security and prosperity. It is imperative to take decisive action to dismantle trafficking networks and ensure that those responsible are held accountable for their actions (Gumilar & Setiyono, 2024). Indonesia, as a major global labor-sending nation, has unfortunately seen a significant number of its citizens become victims of this atrocious crime, and in 2019 alone, the International Labour Organization (ILO) estimated that 3.5 million Indonesian migrant workers were living abroad, with a significant portion of them working in Malaysia (Mahardika & Wicaksono, 2020).

The Riau Islands have become a significant transit point for Indonesian migrant workers due to their proximity to Malaysia, particularly Johor Bahru (Witarti et al., 2013). Due to its large coastline, many small islands, and inaccessible places, monitoring and patrolling the Riau Islands is difficult (Suharnata, 2024). Additionally, lax restrictions and unscrupulous procedures allow human traffickers to operate without consequence. According to Darmayani (2021), traffickers use documentation loopholes or bribery to help victims cross borders. This circumstance allows human trafficking networks to target vulnerable Indonesian migrant laborers seeking jobs in Malaysia.

Indonesian migrant workers in Johor Bahru suffer significant human trafficking issues. Human rights and labor migration policies are affected (Darmayani, 2021). These workers, mostly from rural areas with low education and career possibilities, are more vulnerable to traffickers’ deception (Lestari, 2021). Human traffickers disguise themselves as trustworthy recruiters to exploit victims. However, in Malaysia, these laborers live a dreadful life. Novia and Djelantik (2024) found that passports and identification documents are stolen, limiting people’s mobility and communication. Workers in these conditions work long hours and are abused physically, verbally, and sexually (Kusumawati & Hamrany, 2023).

Exploitation and Vulnerability of Indonesian Migrant Workers in Johor Bahru: A Case Study from the Riau Islands

The challenging expedition embarked upon by Indonesian migrant workers in search of employment in Johor Bahru, Malaysia, is frequently marred by their susceptibility to human trafficking networks that operate in the porous border regions of the Riau Islands. Many workers, who often come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, are enticed by the prospect of improved wages and living conditions. In Malaysia, almost 70% of Indonesian migrant workers are from households that make less than the poverty threshold in their home country (Bait et al., 2024). The appeal of higher wages is quite substantial, as Indonesian migrant workers in Malaysia earn three to four times more than what they would typically earn for similar work in their hometowns (Kusumawati & Hamrany, 2023).

The operations of these trafficking networks are complex, often involving a mix of deceit, manipulation, and brutality. Victims are frequently targeted by individuals who exploit their vulnerability and need for work, often using personal connections or unregulated labor intermediaries (Darmayani, 2021). When they arrive in Johor Bahru, their documents are frequently confiscated, and they are made to labor under abusive conditions for little or no pay while facing continual threats of violence (Gunawan et al., 2022). The issue is further compounded by the absence of strong legal safeguards for undocumented workers, who live in constant fear of deportation and hesitate to report instances of abuse to the authorities (Kurniati, 2023).

The Exploitation of Indonesian Migrant Workers from Riau; Danger in the Coastlines

Because of their distance to Johor Bahru and the high number of illegal border crossings, the Riau Islands have unfortunately become a hub for human trafficking activities. Insufficient border controls give rise to various vulnerabilities that are exploited by human trafficking networks. According to a study conducted by Erawaty et al. in 2024, the Riau Islands are comprised of more than 1,700 islands, some of which have secluded and unmonitored coastlines.

These remote passages are utilized by traffickers to transport victims across the border without being detected (Erawaty et. al., 2024). Furthermore, the presence of corrupt individuals within border agencies or local authorities can contribute to human trafficking facilitation. Officials may be bought off by traffickers to ignore unauthorized crossings or manipulate paperwork (Darmayani, 2021).

The convenience of travel between the Riau Islands and Johor Bahru presents a unique challenge, as informal ferry services and traditional fishing boats are frequently used for border crossings. This creates difficulties in monitoring and controlling movement (Suharnata, 2024). The combination of these factors results in a border environment that is easily exploited by human trafficking networks. The Indonesian government’s attempts to address the issue of human trafficking have faced challenges due to resource constraints, ineffective law enforcement, and a lack of coordination among relevant agencies (Gumilar & Setiyono, 2024).

Human Trafficking of Indonesian Migrant Workers in Johor Bahru: A Critical Analysis of Legal Frameworks, Exploitation, and International Protection

Legal and Policy Frameworks; A Critical Assessment of the Countries’ Policy Outlook

Although both Indonesia and Malaysia have implemented laws and regulations to combat human trafficking, there are doubts about their effectiveness (Indradewi & Ginting, 2024). The Indonesian Law №21 of 2007 addresses the issue of trafficking in persons by providing a comprehensive framework. It covers various aspects, such as preventive measures, protection for victims, and punishment for perpetrators. Nevertheless, the implementation of anti-trafficking initiatives continues to face obstacles such as bureaucratic hurdles, corruption within law enforcement agencies, and insufficient funding (Gumilar & Setiyono, 2024). Comprehensively, the Malaysian Anti-Trafficking in Persons and Anti-Smuggling of Migrants Act 2007 addresses the issue of trafficking by making it a criminal offense and implementing measures to safeguard the rights of victims. Nevertheless, the implementation of the policy is still lacking, as there have been instances of police complacency, witness intimidation, and prolonged court proceedings (Gunawan et al., 2022).

In addition, the dynamic nature of the Indonesia-Malaysia border, especially in Riau, enables unauthorized cross-border activities and intensifies the threat of human trafficking (Darmayani, 2021). The absence of strict border controls and insufficient surveillance systems, along with understaffed and ill-equipped border patrol units, allow traffickers to take advantage of vulnerable individuals who are seeking employment in Malaysia (Erawaty et al., 2024). Dealing with these border-related challenges requires stronger collaboration between Indonesian and Malaysian authorities.

The Vulnerabilities of Indonesian Migrant Workers; Aspects that Led to Exploitation

Indonesian migrant workers in Johor Bahru face a heightened risk of exploitation due to various factors coming together. A significant number of individuals choose to migrate through informal channels, circumventing established recruitment procedures and resulting in a lack of documentation (Dwi, 2021). Without proper legal documentation, these individuals are vulnerable to the whims of their employers. They may face the unjust seizure of their passports, the withholding of their wages, or the imposition of terrible working conditions. The workers’ fear of being deported and their lack of access to legal aid contribute to their continued silence and hinder their ability to advocate for their rights (Kurniati, 2023).

In addition, it is common for Indonesian migrant workers to have a limited command of Bahasa Malaysia, which is the official language of Malaysia. The inability to effectively communicate with employers, authorities, and fellow workers due to the language barrier puts them at a higher risk of being deceived and exploited (Kusumawati & Hamrany, 2023). In addition, a significant number of Indonesian migrant workers, especially women, originate from rural regions where access to education is limited. Insufficient education can result in a lack of awareness regarding their rights, making individuals susceptible to exploitation by traffickers and unethical employers (Fitria, 2023).

When considering gender, the issue of exploitation is particularly worrisome. Many women who migrate for work experience frequent instances of sexual harassment and violence. According to a 2013 Witarti et al. study done in Riau, women migrants are more likely to be employed in domestic settings, where they are especially open to being sexually exploited by their employers or family members.

International Organizations and Protection Schemes; Global Efforts to Protect Indonesian Migrant Workers

International organizations are crucial in providing support for national initiatives aimed at addressing human trafficking and safeguarding the rights of migrant workers. The International Labour Organisation (ILO), a specialized agency of the United Nations, is dedicated to promoting fair and dignified employment while safeguarding the rights of workers, including those who migrate for work. The Forced Labour Protocol of the ILO is a treaty that member states are legally bound to follow. It necessitates that they implement certain measures aimed at preventing and eradicating forced labor, including human trafficking. The ILO offers support to governments and social partners in enhancing legal frameworks, enhancing labor inspections, and promoting awareness about forced labor. In addition, the ILO works together with trade unions, civil society organizations, and the private sector to create and execute successful approaches to addressing human trafficking within the realm of labor migration (Madaniyah et al., 2024).

Another important player in this field is the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), a prominent inter-governmental organization that specializes in addressing migration concerns. The IOM is dedicated to ensuring the smooth and compassionate handling of migration, fostering collaboration on migration matters, and offering support to migrants who require assistance. The IOM is actively involved in addressing the issue of trafficking by increasing public awareness of its dangers, offering protection and aid to victims, and helping them reintegrate into their communities. The IOM collaborates with governments, civil society, and the private sector to enhance national capacities for preventing and tackling human trafficking (Dwi, 2021).

Conclusion and Reccomendation

In conclusion, this article examines the case study of Indonesian migrant workers in Johor Bahru who, regrettably, became victims of human trafficking. Resolving the issue of human trafficking of migrant workers from Indonesia necessitates a multifaceted strategy that addresses the underlying causes of vulnerability, fortifies legal frameworks, improves border security, and promotes international cooperation. In Indonesia and Malaysia, protecting these workers’ rights and dignity is morally critical and necessary for sustained growth.

Several steps are needed to combat human trafficking and protect Indonesian migrant labor. Indonesian and Malaysian authorities must expand remote patrols, improve surveillance, and cooperate to monitor and deter illegal border crossings (Erawaty et al., 2024). Also important is fighting corruption. Border agencies and municipal governments should introduce frequent inspections, transparent reporting, and harsh sanctions for traffickers (Darmayani, 2021).

Indonesia and Malaysia must improve their legal frameworks and enforcement. Anti-trafficking legislation can be improved by streamlining administrative processes, devoting enough resources to enforcement organizations, and prosecuting traffickers quickly and fairly (Gumilar & Setiyono, 2024). Educating potential migrant workers about their rights, trafficking risks, and safe movement may help reduce their vulnerability. Public awareness initiatives targeting communities and local authorities boost anti-trafficking support (Bait et al., 2024).

Victim support must be improved. Legal, medical, psychological, and secure housing support systems assist victims in recovering and reintegrating. Previous studies have shown that integrating with international organizations like the ILO and IOM can boost these efforts (Madaniyah et al., 2024; Dwi, 2021). Progress requires international cooperation. Governments, international organizations, and NGOs may collaborate, share best practices, and protect migratory workers (Langie, 2024).

To prevent trafficking schemes, recruitment agencies must be controlled. Recruitment agency inspections and accreditation can help protect migrant workers’ rights (Kurniati, 2023).

References

Bait, I. Y. P., Mustika, A. D. N., Wibowo, A., Ferdiyansyah, I. D., Krisdiyanto, A., Nawipa, S., Wangge, K. N., Ama, J. T., & Kadir, S. A. (2024). Minimal Socialization to the Community Regarding Legal Requirements for Working Abroad Causes an Increase in Human Trafficking of Workers from East Nusa Tenggara. Journal of Legal and Cultural Analytics, 3(1), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.55927/jlca.v3i1.7817

Darmayani, A. (2021). A Fluid Border? Indonesia-Malaysia Labour Migration and Human Trafficking. https://thesis.eur.nl/pub/61024/Azrina-Darmayani-A-Fluid-Border.-Indonesia-Malaysia-Labour-Migration-and-Human-Trafficking-from-Human-Security-Perspectives.pdf

Dwi, R. (2021). THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION FOR MIGRATION (IOM) IN ADDRESSING HUMAN TRAFFICKING AGAINST INDONESIAN MIGRANT WORKERS IN MALAYSIA POST-COVID-19. Mediasi: Journal of International Relations, 4(2). https://ejournal.unida.gontor.ac.id/index.php/mediasi/article/view/10036/10619

Erawaty, R., Hartiwiningsih, H., & Kurnia, M. P. (2024). Position Strengthening of Cross-Border posts as a filter to international crimes of human trafficking. In Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research/Advances in social science, education and humanities research (pp. 286–290). https://doi.org/10.2991/978-2-38476-218-7_47

Fitria, N. (2023). The urgency of human security in protecting the rights of migrant workers: Case study Indonesian migrant workers in Malaysia and Hong Kong. International Journal of Engineering Business and Social Science, 1(03), 98–105. https://doi.org/10.58451/ijebss.v1i03.28

Flambonita, N. S., Novianti, N. V., & Febriansyah, N. A. (2022). Preventive protection for Indonesian migrant workers as part of an effort to prevent human trafficking in Johor Bahru Malaysia. Journal La Sociale, 3(3), 111–116. https://doi.org/10.37899/journal-la-sociale.v3i3.659

Gumilar, H. R., & Setiyono, J. (2024). The Effectiveness of International Law in Eradicating Human Trafficking in Indonesia: Analysis of Implementation and Challenges. International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding, 11(6), 339–348. http://dx.doi.org/10.18415/ijmmu.v11i6.5929

Gunawan, Y., Farman, L., Jayapraja, L. D., Taufik, M. S. F., & Irrynta, D. (2022). INTERNATIONAL LAW REVIEW ON THE EXPLOITATION AND NEGLECT OF INDONESIAN WORKERS IN MALAYSIA. Wacana Hukum/Wacana Hukum, 28(2). https://doi.org/10.33061/wh.v28i2.8022

Indradewi, A. A., & Ginting, Y. P. (2024). Legal Protection for Indonesian Migrant Workers in International Human Trafficking Syndicates. UNES Law Review, 6(4), 9968–9976. https://doi.org/10.31933/unesrev.v6i4.1831

Kurniati, Y. (2023). Legal Protection For Illegal Indonesian Migrant Workers Victims Of Human Trafficking. Jurnal Info Sains: Informatika dan Sains, 13(02), 41–51. https://ejournal.seaninstitute.or.id/index.php/InfoSains/article/view/2687

Kusumawati, M. P., & Hamrany, A. K. (2023). The exploitation of Indonesian migrant workers when abroad. KnE Social Sciences. https://doi.org/10.18502/kss.v8i9.13342

Langie, R. H. (2024). The Policy of Combating Trafficking in Persons: Assessing the Global Political and the Current Economic Development. Sch Int J Law Crime Justice, 7(5), 190–195. https://saudijournals.com/media/articles/SIJLCJ_75_190-195.pdf

Lestari, S. E. (2021). Protection of constitutional rights against Indonesian women workers. Linguistics and Culture Review, 5(S1), 710–725. https://doi.org/10.21744/lingcure.v5ns1.1458

Ma’ruf, D. M. R. S. (2023). Legal protection of Indonesian migrant workers reviewed according to Law Number 18 of 2017 concerning the protection of Indonesian migrant workers. Rechtsnormen, 2(1), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.55849/rjl.v2i1.496

Madaniyah, A. S., Sophianandita, D. P., Irawan, P. T., & Silalahi, Y. L. (2024). The Role of the International Labour Organization (ILO) in the Protection of the Human Rights of Indonesian Migrant Workers. Synergisia, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.62872/23p22d10

Mahardika, A. P., & Wicaksono, S. S. (2020). Human Trafficking and Migrant Workers: Analysis of Indonesian migrant workers protection in overseas. Law Research Review Quarterly, 6(2), 173–180. https://doi.org/10.15294/lrrq.v6i2.37366

Novia, H., & Djelantik, S. (2024). Indonesia Diplomacy in Protecting the Rights of Indonesian Migrant Domestic Workers in Malaysia (2017–2022). Insignia: Journal of International Relations, 11(1), 51–69. https://doi.org/10.20884/1.ins.2024.11.1.10087

Prananda, M. T. (2024). Perlindungan Hukum Bagi Pekerja Migran Indonesia Korban Kejahatan Perdagangan Orang Dalam Perspektif Hukum Ketenagakerjaan. Media Hukum Indonesia (MHI), 2(2). http://repository.unpas.ac.id/id/eprint/69096

Rini, F. S., & Prastyanti, R. A. (2024). Legal Protection for Victims of Human Trafficking: Indonesian Migrant Workers Abroad. International Journal of Sociology and Law, 1(2), 01–08. https://doi.org/10.62951/ijsl.v1i2.32

Riyanto, S., Firdaus, Y., & Sumerhu, H. (2024). Protection Of The Constitutional Rights Of Indonesian Women Workers In Malaysia. The International Journal of Law Review and State Administration, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.58818/ijlrsa.v2i1.100

Suharnata, S. (2024). Challenges in ratifying ILO Convention C188 for the protection of Indonesian migrant fishers: case study on Riau Islands Province. In Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research/Advances in social science, education and humanities research (pp. 259–277). https://doi.org/10.2991/978-2-38476-208-8_30

Witarti, D. , Faradina, S. , Ridaryanthi, M. , and A. Puspita. 2013. Exploring the Impact of Human Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation Toward Women Migrant Workers: A Case Study in Riau, Indonesia. PUP Social Sciences and Development Review Journal, 05(01), 1–11. https://serp-p.pids.gov.ph/publication/public/view?slug=exploring-the-impact-of-human-trafficking-and-sexual-exploitation-toward-women-migrant-workers-a-ca